Tile or Asphalt Shingles: Which One is Best for your Roof

Deciding as to what type of material is best for your roof is one of the most difficult decisions that you need to take when installing a new roof. This involves paying attention to various aspects like quality, longevity, and price of a particular material.

Usually, what you see around your neighborhood is that most of the roofs have asphalt shingles. But this doesn’t suggest that it is an appropriate choice for your home’s roof. To give you an idea, we have drawn a comparison between the tiles and asphalt shingles by considering their performance, durability, and cost factor. So, prior to buying a new roof, make sure to keep these essential aspects in mind.

What Climate do you live in?

If you live in an area, which experiences harsh weather conditions through most of the time of a year, you need strong protection for the roof. For instance, if there are freezing temperatures or high winds, you must consider the durability factor when installing a new roof.

Although asphalt shingles cost you less, they fail to endure the lashes of Mother Nature. They usually wrap up or break down after being exposed to strong winds or heat for a few years. Tiles, on the other hand, can withstand winds up to 180 mph, pass Grade-1 freeze-thaw requirements, and absorb minimum heat.


In most of the cases, roof replacement may turn out to be an expensive cut on your budget. So if you are tight on budget, it would be wise to go for asphalt shingles when you need to replace your home’s roof.


Asphalt shingles are less effective when it comes to durability. Even if you find them affordable upfront, they might cost you a lot in terms of replacing the roof after 10 years or so. Since concrete tiles are known for their resistance against severe heat or cold, they are usually recommended for all weather conditions.

Which one is more Energy Efficient?

If you are sick and tired of bearing cooling and heating costs, it’s time to make your home more energy efficient than ever. How?—it’s simple. By just insulating your roof with energy efficient roofing materials, you can lower the air conditioning costs.

During winters, your home loses most of its heat through its roof. This suggests that you need to heat your home continuously to maintain a comfortable room temperature. Similar is the case in the summer, where a considerable rise in temperature in the attic makes it difficult to cool your home.

So, what material you should use when installing a new roof? Asphalt shingles absorb most of the heat; hence, they aren’t something that you should consider when living in a hot climate. On the contrary, tiles reflect sunshine and heat, making them an ideal option for maintaining a comfortable temperature indoors.

If your budget doesn’t allow you to choose concrete roof tiles, you better consult a professional roofer to know whether you can get heat resistant asphalt shingles. By doing so, you can find a few options that may fit into your budget.

Think about Contacting a Reliable Roofer

When you are all set to install a new roof, the next step is to contact a roofing contractor.   For this purpose, you should hire the best in the business, capable of meeting all your roofing needs within a set budget. 

Scroll to Top